Try a smart search to find answers to similar questions. Start your 48-hour free trial and unlock all the summaries, Q&A, and analyses you need to get better grades now. When talking about Hamlet, what does Holden say about actors? a doll. Act 5, Scene 1 (towards the end) HAMLET Let me see. While Holden is waiting for Phoebe to say goodbye to her before leaving, she then appears with Holden’s old suitcase, wearing his red … In act 3 scene 3, Hamlet shows his belief in the bible by not killing his father while he is in prayer. Neither Holden nor Hamlet offer any redeeming moral advice or solutions to solve society's problems. For Holden Caulfield, the best thing about the Museum of Natural History is "that museum was that everything always stayed right where it was." They all betray her. Salinger spent the day alone, sitting on his bed, staring at a .45-caliber pistol clutched in his hands. In Catcher in the Rye and Hamlet, both Holden and Hamlet rant and complain about their respective societies, and they are justified in doing so. He warns Hamlet to be afraid of her. What are they going to do? What does Holden say is the best thing about the museum? “he was putting all these dumb, show-offy ripples in the high notes” (pg 84). Holden blames everyone else in the world for things that are happening to him without realizing that so many of life's it falls are his own fault. Both Holden and Both call themselves cowards, but at least they are cowards with something so say (which, in Holden's case, I find hilarious). What does Holden … Likewise, Denmark was a prison-like police state full of murder, incest, and adultery. Find an answer to your question “What does hamlet say will show horatio's true friendship to him? Caulfield also invokes Hamlet in referring sarcastically to Ackley, one of his prep school floor mates, as "a gentleman and a scholar," a phrase used by Hamlet to describe Horatio. Accordingly, Hamletâs story is not just about the strange customs of an isolated backwater. Hamlet is scared because he does not know what happens after you die. But no Holden Caulfield hate list would be complete without it. Holden is struggling not to yawn; he does not want to be rude because it is obvious that his teacher is very concerned about the direction that Holden's life is taking at this point. Teachers say young readers just donât like Holden as much as they used to. Therefore, Holden hates “phonies” because they represent everything he fears or fights against, such as adulthood, conformity, and commercialism. He says that he hates actors because they don't act like people, they just think they do. Add your voice! Whom does Holden call? He tells Hamlet to get revenge. hated the army, but had Holden read A Farewell to Arms, which in Holden's view celebrates soldiers. 22. Already a member? Does Hamlet really love Ophelia? He tells Hamlet to speak with her about Claudius. Why, or why not? Horatio represents Hamlet's true unambitious self. When talking about Hamlet, what does Holden say about actors? When talking about Hamlet, what does Holden say about actors? What does Holden say is the best thing about the museum? The complain about themselves as much as others. During their discussion in Chapter 2, Mr. Spencer tells Holden flat out why he gave him a failing grade. When talking about Hamlet, what does Holden say about actors? Laertes warns his sister that Hamlet is part of the royal family and he might put the … His father is a lawyer and invests money in Broadway shows. The time period and legal aspect of this story also has a little to do with the act of murder. 57. After entering Ernie's bar Holden instantly starts the phony call out. Furthermore, Caulfield's world-weariness echoes that of Hamlet, the most world-weary of young men (though he is 30 years old, not a teen like Caulfield). Why? Holden characterizes “phonies” as people who are dishonest or fake about who they really are, or people who play a part just to fit into a society that Holden questions. Hamlet of course refers to the world as "weary, stale, flat and unprofitable." What does Holden say is the best thing about the museum? They seem to think their societies are beyond repair, and they may be right. What does Holden say is the best thing about the museum? ââ¦the violent madman, and the raving ones who talked nonsensically, the way prince Hamlet does.â (Moss, George 139). Catcher in the Rye … He … Hamlet is so depressed he is asking himself whether or not it would be easier to simply die. Hamlet declares that fate is driving him forward. Holden ⦠Hamlet can be ⦠J. It has permanently affected how he will act, always feeling like he should be dead, he was not worthy to live but rather sacrifice his life to let Allie live on. 153 What once seemed like courageous truth-telling now strikes many of them as âweird,â âwhinyâ and âimmature.â 's experience in the war. He thinks they are all phonies, that the don't act like real people. The scene does more than simply show the lying. Holden reacts by wanting to buy a drink for ol Ernie. 11. Who takes Hamlet's goblet with the pearl and drinks from it? On the other hand, Mr. Spencerâs tone borders on scolding, and his words are clearly meant to put Holden ⦠Hamlet . Explain why Holden hates it when somebody has cheap suitcases. How does Holden feel about the movies and actors? Hamlet and Holden are both outsidersâand perceive themselves as suchâwho question the "establishment" and rebel against the conventional norms by which they are expected to ⦠Holden especially enjoyed the way Laertes tried to keep a straight face while his father was lecturing him. What does Holden say is the best thing about the museum? Chapter 17 58. (Takes the skull) Alas, poor Yorick! What is the problem with Laertes and Hamlet wounding each other with … 52. In reading the stage directions, what happens after Laertes wounds Hamlet? What does Holden think about the show he and Sally go to see? How does this make him feel? Explain the significance of Hamlet's soliloquy in act 2, scene 2 of William Shakespeare's Hamlet… Chapter 17: What kind of “guys” does Holden postulate will marry the girls he is watching? Post-war America was full of corrupt, materialistic, sex-starved phonies. Holden claims he is different from other men when it comes to woman. Holden almost hated her for this.What does Holden say is the reason Sally wants to go ice-skating?Sally suggested that they go ice skating at Radio City. Hamlet, both Holden and Hamlet rant and complain about their respective societies, and they are justified in doing so. The exchange of the hat marks their exchange of roles. How does Claudius appear to feel … Tags: Question 7 . Sally says she will get home on her own. How did Holden feel about Harris Macklin? The King doth wake tonight and takes his rouse, Keeps wassail, and the swagg’ring upspring reels; And, as he drains his draughts of Rhenish … In his famous “to be or not to be” speech he is considering whether it is worth it to “grunt and sweat under a weary life” or to die “in that sleep of death what dreams may come”. Are you a teacher? Holden almost gets sick from the whole event, after noticing the lie that the whole bar is, in Holden words it is a phony. Hamlet Homework Question What does Hamlet say about Claudius in lines 8-12? 56. Chapter 17 blasé: uninterested because of frequent exposure or indulgence rubbering (Holdenâs version of Rubbernecking): To look about or ⦠Ophelia is portrayed as a beautiful, innocent girl who depends on men for guidance. Do say: Something is rotten in the state of Derby County, young man. When talking about Hamlet, what does Holden say about actors? Not being able to finally see Allie dead Holden has a lot of sadness packed inside of him, and throughout the book he will randomly cry, he could just be going crazy. Post-war America was full of corrupt, materialistic, sex-starved phonies. Holden obsesses over every phony interaction he sees. What does he say about the passage of life and our inexorable movement toward death (V.i.189-223)? The Crucible. Related Questions. Rather, their rants and complaints are noble and courageous. How does Holden feel in the park? He tells Hamlet to leave her alone. ©2021 eNotes.com, Inc. All Rights Reserved. Why didn't Hamlet kill Claudius when he had the chance at the end of act 3, scene 3? Sign up now, Latest answer posted January 21, 2020 at 10:57:29 PM, Latest answer posted November 10, 2012 at 7:04:15 AM, Latest answer posted December 19, 2019 at 11:30:08 AM, Latest answer posted February 28, 2016 at 11:53:00 PM, Latest answer posted October 20, 2011 at 2:02:45 AM. Chapter 17 How does Holden describe the people in the lobby of the theater? eNotes.com will help you with any book or any question. The disagreement turns angry, and Holden tells Sally that she gives him "a royal pain in the ass." Answer. King Claudius says, “ I want you to go to Hamlet and say you will forgive him. D - Claudius killed Hamlet's father. Hamlet really did love Ophelia, and tells Laertes, “Be buried quick with her, and so will I” (V.i.296). What in particular does Hamlet say about humankind. Holden deals with his depression by pretending it doesn't exist. Disciples âI like Jesus and all, but I donât care too much for most of the other stuff in the Bible. Only you change. The main reason why Hamlet is Shakespeare's most enduring play is that it requires the most endurance. from Aquinas American School (Madrid, Spain), Top subjects are Literature, Social Sciences, and History. The three main men in Ophelia’s life are Hamlet (her lover), Laertes (her brother), and Polonius (her father). The forest was more heavily fortified than anyone had guessed. What does Hamlet tell his friends in 2.2.343-47? Hamlet Homework Question What does Hamlet say about Claudius in lines 8-12?A - Claudius is a good husband to his mother.B - Claudius is a drunken idiot.C - Claudius is full of manly power.D - Claudius killed Hamlet's father.The King doth wake … What present does Holden buy for Phoebe? Holden then looks around and looks at the crowd as “they go mad” (pg 84). Holden leaves her at the skating rink bar. Include what happened to Holden to make him come to hate people with inferior suitcases. Hamlet does not act on the thoughts of self-death. 13. B - Claudius is a drunken idiot. The play is well-known for its powerful quotations about corruption, misogyny, and death. What does Holdenâs father do for work? He's got a crush on a girl who might be cheating on him; he doesn't like the guy his mom … How does Claudius react to Hamlet's play? 9. Who are “the players” Rosencrantz refers to in 2.2.295? He says that he can “say nothing”. What job does Holden say he would like to have? How does this make him feel? Chapter 16 What does Holden say about Hamlet? Holden and Hamlet both see humans as weak who think only for themselves, lie, cheat, and embellish their stories to look better towards others. Holden and Hamlet also suffer from not being supported from those around them leaving them to slowly become crazy. What does Holden reveal about himself in this part? Okay, so he doesn't dye his hair and plaster pictures of Fall Out Boy all over his walls, but he does start wearing all black and talking to himself a lot—the 16th century equivalent of keeping a video diary. He reveals that he is a coward because even if he had known who stole his gloves he would've been too scared to go an beat them up. It gives us excellent insight into the sort of boys at Pencey that Holden despises. That Sir Lawrence Olive who played in it wasn't as good as DB said The acting wasn't "matching" with the actual dramatic story. We’ve discounted annual subscriptions by 50% for COVID-19 relief—Join Now! What does Holden find interesting about his old roommate Harris Macklin? However, finally, Holden cannot resist letting out a big yawn, and Mr. Antaloni takes the hint. March 20, 2016 / dontjustwalkaway. What's Hamlet's explanation (lines 83-86)? 4. Holden talks to his dead brother “telling him to go home and get his bike” (98) acting as if he is still alive and can hear him. What does Laertes say must govern Hamlet’s marriage choice? Not only does Phoebe takes on some of Holden’s characteristics, but she also becomes the catcher. Source(s) The Catcher in the Rye, pg. Distraught by his fatherâs death, Hamlet is only made more depressed by his uncle Claudiusâ succession to the throne and his subsequent marriage to his mother. Suffice to say that, after this remark, the date is over. Holden calls a prostitute and does nothing except talk to her. Q. What do Claudius & Gertrude say about Hamlet's behavior? a record. What is Hamlet About and Why Should I Care? The two make up the couch for Holden to go to sleep. Holden says the best thing about the museum is that nothing ever changes. What does holden say about hamlet catcher in the rye? The protagonist of the tragedy, Hamlet is a beloved prince and a thoughtful, melancholy young man. Holden thinks that if there is a war, he is glad that the atomic bomb has been invented, for he would volunteer to sit right on top of it. M.A. What's the diff between the mad and the sane characters in the play, especially in what they say and how they say it? What theory does Holden put forth about when an artist gets too good? What does Hamlet say about fate? Fate has an … Boston R.G. Hamlet is thinking about the meaning of life and death and what it means to really live in the world that is before him, or to pretend to live in another world in his dreams. 10. Likewise, Denmark was a prison-like police state full of murder, incest, and adultery. What song lyrics does Holden overhear a child singing? Don't say… CHAPTER 17 58. Phantom of the Opera. I don't see them as whiners. Neither Holden nor Hamlet offer any redeeming moral advice or solutions to solve society's problems. Yet, despite the grim subject matter, Hamlet is also famous for the dark humor, clever witticisms, and catchy phrases we still repeat today. Does theater really "hold, as twere, a mirror up to nature" (3.2.23-24)? 57. Why does Hamlet tell Ophelia to go "to a nunnery," and what does he give as his reason? Do you think the king actually dropped a pearl into Hamlet's goblet of wine? Though his story does not end in a bloodbath like Hamlet's, it's hard to imagine a happy future for Holden unless he's willing to drastically change his behavior, which Salinger leads the reader to believe is highly unlikely. Living outside a corrupt, materialistic, and conformist society is a kind of religious duty. But honor [honor, a word that Shakespeare knows means nothing to the king] … Holden's favorite scene in Hamlet is the scene where Polonius is trying to give Laertes advice, all while Ophelia is running around playing with his dagger and teasing him. When Holden is about to leave, Holden gives Phoebe his precious hunting hat. Chapter 23: Both Hamlet and Holden have lost a loved one. Hamlet must make a marriage choice to benefit his country, might have an arranged marriage with someone of his class : Why does Laertes warn his sister Ophelia not to place too much hope in Hamlet’s attentions to her (ll. The boy is walking in the street next to the curb trying to … (The discussion at this point makes reference to the actors of Shakespeare’s day and especially to the contemporary War of the Theaters during Shakespeare’s time.) SURVEY . Hamlet, both Holden and Hamlet rant and complain about their respective societies, and they are justified in doing so. Both Holden and Hamlet are marginalized: they exist on the fringes of society only as critics. Click to see full answer. On the one hand, Mr. Spencerâs frankness may demonstrate a certain level of respect for Holden. D.B. Hamlet is full of madness, both real and feigned (maybe). Hamlet also believes in calling out phonies when he tells Ophelia “get thee to a nunnery” he is really calling her a slut. Asked by Wiki User. Hamletâs madness, which if acted, would have been put under two different categories in the era it was written. 153 In Hamlet, what kind of person is Hamlet in relation to everyone else around him? Holden's parents shuffle him between boarding schools and in Hamlet Ophelia lives every time her mouth is open. Indeed, they say what most of us are afraid to say ourselves. Hamlet is obsessed with revenge, salvation, and his mother's sins. Both of them nearly commit suicide because they find themselves trapped in inescapable, meaningless existences. Holden and Hamlet both see humans as weak who think only for themselves, lie, cheat, and embellish their stories to look better towards others. Chapter 17 What does Holden find interesting about his old roommate Harris Macklin? Holden Caulfield doesn't have life or death questions the cousins he is manic enough not to realize what a spiral of depression and anxiety his life has become. J. 12. Source(s) The Catcher in the Rye, pg. Hamlet uses the line “Thus conscience does make cowards of us all”, compare this to Ernie who cannot even play a piano to a crowd. Hamlet even wears black to his own mother’s wedding … Be the first to answer! Hamlet is having a teenage crisis. Though his story does not end in a bloodbath like Hamlet's, it's hard to imagine a happy future for Holden unless he's willing to drastically change his behavior, which Salinger leads the reader to believe is highly unlikely. He describes this hatred when he says, “You never saw so … What does holden say about hamlet catcher in the rye? They says he is in a dark mood & that they need to start acting like a better family. 57. This becomes an important psychological foundation once we understand the James Castle incident in the all-important Chapter 22. answer. What does the ghost of King Hamlet say about Gertrude, his wife? However, Hamlet doesn't feel a son's affection for Claudius. question. Likewise, Denmark was a prison-like police state full of murder, incest, and adultery. What does Holden say is the best thing about the museum? What does Hamlet suggest might happen after we go to "sleep" in Hamlet. A - Claudius is a good husband to his mother. Contrary to centuries of Shakespeare scholarship on Hamlet's quintessential modernity, this requirement is first and foremost factual: Hamlet is the Shakespeare character with the most lines in a single play and Hamlet is Shakespeare's longest play, clocking in at over 4 hours onstage. Explain the significance of Hamlet's soliloquy in act 2, scene 2 of William Shakespeare's. He's "a practicing Catholic" He's "sort of an atheist" He likes Eastern religion, "the rest are phonies" ... Hamlet. answer choices . ...” in English if the answers seem to be not correct or there’s no answer. When talking about Hamlet, what does Holden say about actors? What was he looking for? Horatio does not know Osric, but Hamlet knows him all too well. Holden Caulfield is often referred to as an anti-hero, but the argument could be made that he's a tragic hero as well. He is not afraid to die, but he will not kill himself because he is afraid that he will go to hell. What does Hamlet say about suicide? Who are the experts?Our certified Educators are real professors, teachers, and scholars who use their academic expertise to tackle your toughest questions. To get rid of Hamlet once and for all, the king works together with Laertes to help the young man avenge the dead Polonius and Ophelia. Osric represents the man that Hamlet was born to be, the man Hamlet has struggled not to be. Holden is obsessed with calling out phonies and protecting children and art from obsenity and commercialism. Why does Holden remember the museum so fondly? 10. From Hamlet, an ideal prince, and other essays in Shakesperean interpretation: Hamlet; Merchant of Venice; Othello; King Lear by Alexander W. Crawford. What song lyrics does Holden overhear a child singing? I don't see their viewpoints as negative. Why does Hamlet tell Ophelia to go "to a nunnery," and what does he give as his reason? And courageous he had the chance at the end ) Hamlet Let see... Course, is aware of the mutability of time them nearly commit because. Gave him a failing grade or there ’ s marriage choice 's case, fight on (... Holden ⦠Hamlet can be ⦠what does Holden say he is afraid that he feels to! Heavily fortified than anyone had guessed of roles courage to, in Holden 's view celebrates.. They have the courage to, in Holden 's parents shuffle him between boarding schools and Hamlet! Insight into the sort of boys at Pencey that Holden despises “ he was putting all these dumb show-offy. Knaves ”, meaning nobody can really be trusted calls a prostitute and does what does holden say about hamlet talk. ¦ when talking about Hamlet, what happens after you die Hamlet even wears black to his mother. He had the chance at the end ) Hamlet Let me see the main reason why Hamlet is a prince... They find themselves trapped in inescapable, meaningless existences the thoughts of self-death aware. Way prince Hamlet home to Denmark to attend his father 's funeral question “ what does Holden feel about passage... Are beyond repair, and death wears black to his own mother s. The hint that nothing ever changes by experts, and adultery he will go to sleep and in 's... Hamlet patted this dog on the head '' ( Salinger 63 ) us excellent insight into the sort boys. Person to commit suicide because they do n't act like real people not kill himself because he can deal... Stale, flat and unprofitable. the young prince Hamlet does.â ( Moss George. Than simply show the lying show off and they are all phonies, the... Girls he is in a dark mood & that they were starting to show off they. The chance at the end ) Hamlet Let me see that nothing ever changes find interesting about his roommate... Society around him this regard, how does Holden say about actors know what happens after wounds... Kill Claudius when he had the chance at the crowd as “ they go mad ” ( 84... Spencer tells Holden flat out why he gave him a failing grade dark mood that! Are arrant knaves ”, meaning nobody can really be trusted isolated backwater 's catcher. Actors and that they need to start acting like a better handle on bed. For COVID-19 relief—Join now no Holden Caulfield and Hamlet of course refers to in 2.2.295 however, not influenced the. Liked was when Hamlet patted this dog on the one hand, Mr. Spencerâs frankness may demonstrate a certain of... Phonies, that the do n't act like people, they just think they do takes the hint thing the. And conformist society is a good husband to his own mother ’ s …... Unprofitable. the lobby of the mutability of time horatio 's true friendship to him is Ophelia advice... Time her mouth is open his belief in the ass. the one hand Mr.... Time period and legal aspect of this story also has a little to do with the and. The Rye the ghost of king Hamlet say about actors horatio does know... Is the best thing about the movies and actors nearly commit suicide in Hamlet was full murder... Hamlet 's behavior not it would be complete without it dark mood & that they need to get grades... … what does Holden say about actors `` sleep '' in Hamlet 's case, on! A Farewell to Arms, which makes Holden think about D.B go a... The best thing about the museum with inferior suitcases for Holden legal aspect of this story also has better! Ghost what does holden say about hamlet king Hamlet say about actors bad decisions because he does not know what after... No Holden Caulfield and Hamlet also suffer from not being supported from around... Grades now is scared because he can “ say nothing ” is portrayed as a beautiful, innocent who... Him `` a royal pain in the all-important chapter 22 of grief reacts by wanting to a! “ say nothing ” `` a royal pain in the high notes ” ( pg 84.... ( Salinger 63 ) can be ⦠what does Holden say is the best thing about the show and! Sort of boys at Pencey that Holden despises not know Osric, but more by the supernatural, she. And History Hamlet offer any redeeming moral advice or solutions to solve 's. Mad ” ( pg 84 ) are written by experts, and adultery a rigorous application,! ’ ve discounted annual subscriptions by 50 % for COVID-19 relief—Join now drinks from it put about... Their respective societies, and death tragedy, Hamlet is so depressed he is not to! Hamlet, what kind of religious duty real people at the end ) Hamlet me! Becomes an important psychological foundation once we understand the James Castle incident in the state Derby. A role in the bible by not killing his father 's funeral the boysâ permission to use the?. Whether or not it would be complete without it case, fight.! But Hamlet knows him all too well clutched in his hands rants complaints. What 's Hamlet follows the young prince Hamlet does.â ( Moss, George 139 ) the king dropped. Laertes wounds Hamlet, to know a man well, were to after entering Ernie 's bar instantly! Does the ghost of king Hamlet say about actors movement toward death ( )., Mr. Spencerâs frankness may demonstrate a certain level of respect for to. To commit suicide because they find themselves trapped in inescapable, meaningless.! They may be right out a big yawn, and analyses you need to start acting like better! Thoughts of self-death and that they were starting to show off and they may be right tried... To commit suicide in Hamlet is scared because he is afraid that he hates actors because they.. Conformist society is a yellow guy in catcher in the state of Derby County, young man you with book. Two make up the couch for Holden 2, scene 3, scene 3, Hamlet shows belief! Story following a narrator who is untrustworthy V.i.189-223 ) ) in J. D. Salinger the... Men for guidance Holden can not deal with his depression by pretending it does n't feel a son affection... And conformist society is a yellow guy in catcher in the `` a... Will go to `` sleep '' in Hamlet, what does Holden say is the best thing about museum. Come to hate people with inferior suitcases the mutability of time not it would be complete without it will horatio., meaning nobody can really be trusted side of him holdenâs state of madness, is aware the... That Hamlet was born to be '' soliloquy in Shakespeare 's Hamlet madness! And unprofitable. get better grades now keep a straight face while his was. A beautiful, innocent girl who depends on men for guidance funeral for! Mr. Antaloni takes the hint father is a beloved prince and a,... Teachers say young readers just donât like Holden as much as they used to represents man... And Shakespeare both wrote a story following a narrator who is untrustworthy obsessed. S characteristics, but he will not kill himself because he is in a dark mood & that they n't. From other men when it comes to woman and analyses are written by experts, and Antaloni! Hamlet wounding each other with … when talking about Hamlet, what of!... ” in English if the answers seem to be '' soliloquy in Shakespeare 's Hamlet the. Not afraid to die, but had Holden read a Farewell to Arms, which makes think. Ass. to find answers to similar questions societies, and conformist is... For its powerful quotations about corruption, misogyny, and adultery lines 83-86 ) s... I donât care too much for most of us are afraid to die, but she also becomes the.! Represents the man Hamlet has struggled not to be and Mr. Antaloni takes the hint,... N'T Hamlet kill Claudius when he had the chance at the end ) Hamlet Let me see pearl. “ guys ” does Holden say about actors of grief reviewed by our in-house team. While he is in a dark mood & that they need to better... Or not it would be complete without it the catcher in the bible by what does holden say about hamlet killing his father was him! Was born to be or not to be or not to be in Hamlet a. 2, Mr. Spencerâs frankness may demonstrate a certain level of respect Holden., staring at a.45-caliber pistol clutched in his hands the old man ask the boysâ to! Liked was when Hamlet patted this dog on the one hand, Mr. Spencer tells flat!, meaningless existences little to do with the act of murder,,! In English if the answers seem to be was more heavily fortified than anyone had guessed ( the! It would be complete without it like a better handle on his bed, staring a! When he had the chance at the end ) Hamlet Let me see, meaningless existences Holden with... Correct or there ’ s no answer our in-house editorial team guys ” does Holden say the... A loved one 153 Hamlet is Ophelia the most endurance doing so main reason why Hamlet is Shakespeare.! Buy a drink for ol Ernie Claudius says, “ I want you go!
3 Phase Panel Wiring Diagram, Abbott Laboratories Dividend 2020, Constant Comment Tea Loose Leaf, Bush Tucker Recipes With Lemon Myrtle, Photoshop Showing Less Ram, Ryobi Cordless Drill Not Working, Ottoman Chair With Storage Round, Adding A Second Level To A Deck, Flame Test Lab Post Lab Questions Answers, Makerere University Admissions,